I had actually planned to buy this one based on my approval of Steven Wilson's live DVD from a few weeks ago. BKP also sent the band's "Signify (Expanded Version)" from the mid-90's, which I believe was when this configuration of PT debuted. I had not gone back quite that far in the catalog when I first discovered the band ten years ago. I played this live CD through once and thought.....meh. Gave Signify a spin and went back to Twisted Octane for another cycle. Then it dawned on me...Porcupine Tree HAS run its course, as it has been rumored. Now I hear the rehashed riffs and themes, and in this concert recording, that's indifference in Wilson's voice, not an off night. The first hour of the show from Chicago is basically a Hard Rock Classic Albums Live version of the last (and, God forbid, final) album, "The Incident." I'll just go back to play the studio version. Hour two was better, but not by much. One nice segueing of a couple of favorites but overall uninspiring.
My heart is saddened that this chapter of Wilson's creativity may be closing, as is his work in Blackfield, according to reports. Lord knows he needs to slam the book shut on Storm Corrosion. I anxiously await his next solo project, "The Raven That Refused To Sing (and other stories)," which arrives in late February. Trust me, it will go straight to the front of the line, even if I have fifteen other records in front of it. I also plan on asking...no, telling...Mrs. Rocker to buy me a ticket to his concert in St. Pete in April as my birthday gift. Correct, that's A ticket...there is absolutely zero chance she would go with me.
I honestly had no plans at all to buy this. The other mini-reunions had been so.....Porcupine Tree-like. Where BKP said it sucked, that Page had phoned it in, I was pleasantly surprised once I got past the opening three songs. I turned it off after those first fifteen minutes, nearly junking the whole project without further review. Somewhere on Facebook, I commented as such on a post, and my old M4L buddy, Doxey, chimed in and said it truly improved after the quarter-hour warm up. And he was right. I'll give it a 7 on a 10 scale.








